Author: Kate Colyer
Colyer, Kate, 2015 DEVELOPMENT OF A SPECTROSCOPIC METHOD FOR THE NON-DESTRUCTIVE ANALYSIS OF AUSTRALIAN ABORIGINAL OCHRE MATERIALS, Flinders University, School of Chemical and Physical Sciences
This electronic version is made publicly available by Flinders University in accordance with its open access policy for student theses. Copyright in this thesis remains with the author. This thesis may incorporate third party material which has been used by the author pursuant to Fair Dealing exceptions. If you are the owner of any included third party copyright material and/or you believe that any material has been made available without permission of the copyright owner please contact firstname.lastname@example.org with the details.
This thesis details the work undertaken towards and the results obtained from the development of a portable and non-destructive technique for the analysis of Australian Aboriginal ochre materials. Many of the methods traditionally utilised for analysis are limiting due to their cost, lack of portability, the sample requirements and the destructive nature of analysis. This thesis explores these traditional methods before developing and optimising a spectroscopy based technique that reduces or eliminates many of these and other limitations. Chapter one explores the historical context of pigments. It investigates what a pigment is chemically and visually, whilst exploring many of the pigments used throughout the ages and their evolution over time across the globe. This chapter then discusses early pigments commonly utilised in Australia, and focuses on ochre as the main pigment used by Aboriginal Australians. This study focuses on the significance of ochre to the Aboriginal culture, the chemistry of ochre and the factors that influence its varied colour, and how the structure of ochre changes with heat treatments. This chapter investigates previous scientific studies conducted on ochre and similar pigments across the globe. It explores the work of others and investigates the analytical methods and instrumentation used for analysis, the results obtained from this work, and the advantages and disadvantages of each technique utilised. Chapter two focuses on the characterisation of ochre samples via the use of commonly utilised traditional analytical techniques including X-Ray diffraction analysis, neutron activation analysis, infrared analysis, Raman spectroscopy and thermal gravimetric analysis. The analysis concentrates on ten samples obtained by the mining commission chosen because their colour and composition varied, their province was known, they were from a trusted source and they had been used in previous studies thus allowing for accurate comparisons. It details the experimental methods used for the work completed for this project. It denotes the sample type, locality and province studied, the chemical composition of standards, the instrument models used for any analysis, and the modes of operation and specific parameters used. These samples are analysed using the traditional methods of analysis discussed in chapter one, and results are presented. Chapter three is a preliminary study into the use of a newly emerging instrument known as the X-Rite i1Pro. This instrument is UV-based, portable and non-destructive, and its application to ochre and similar pigments is novel. This chapter discusses the technical aspects of the instrument and the experimental setups utilised before exploring the feasibility of such an application by studying a range of haematite and goethite standards of known mixture compositions. This chapter explores the instruments' ability to detect colour and distinguish between samples of varying colour, before determining the accuracy and reproducibility of these measurements. Experiments then move from standards to the mining samples discussed previously and this chapter presents the results of their analysis with this new and emerging technique. The range of samples is then expanded to include some from an ethnographic collection, and are also analysed utilising a traditional, laboratory lased, bench top grade UV-vis, with the results of the two instruments compared. Work expands to establish a suitable model for the prediction of sample composition, again centring on a range of haematite and goethite standards of known mixture compositions and investigates a number of statistical methods of analysis. Studies include single wave length analysis, a model based on ∆E, and multiple linear regression analysis. The results of each model are presented here. This chapter also investigates the effect of a variety of sample preparation methods to explore the suitability of this instrument to artefacts and images of unknown origin. It explores the effect of sample thickness, and application method including the use of a variety of binders. Statistical analysis is completed in this chapter. Chapter four focuses on the effect of the substrate on the i1Pro results, as it is hypothesised that factors such as surface roughness and colour may influence the spectra obtained. A number of wood and stone based substrates are investigated, and the prediction models developed in chapter three are applied. Chapter five explores the application of the X-Rite i1-Pro system to a number of well-provenanced raw ochre materials from well-known sites significant to Aboriginal Australians. This chapter aims to determine if the inter-site variation is smaller than the intra-site variation, and if the samples analysed from each site can be statistically linked with the hope that unknowns could be tested and preliminarily provenanced. This chapter presents background information, sample information, experimental methods and the results of the study including statistical analysis. The same raw ochre samples are then analysed utilising neutron activation analysis and the results of the two methods are compared. Chapter six is a case study focusing on the application of the X-Rite i1-Pro system to toas of cultural significant to Aboriginal Australians. This chapter presents background information on the significance of the toas, sample information, experimental methods and the results of the study. Results include the statistical analysis of the spectra obtained, and comparisons between the ochre found on the toas and material identified as possible source material. Chapter seven presents the conclusions reached from the research detailed here. It also presents hypotheses for ongoing work, and future directions for this and associated projects. Appendix A presents a study completed into the formation of haematite via the dehydration of goethite. This is culturally significant as many sources and indeed colours of ochre were held in higher regard than others by Aboriginal Australians, and an understanding into the chemistry of alteration was necessary. This appendix presents background and sample information, as well as experimental techniques and results obtained from the use of both thermal gravimetric analysis studies and X-Ray diffraction analysis. Appendix B presents a case study into the accumulation of a dust-like particle on the surface of Aboriginal Rock Art at Arkaroo Rock in the Flinders Rangers South Australia. Background information and photographs, experimental techniques and results of the analysis utilising microscopy, X-ray diffraction, thermal gravimetric analysis and colour analysis with the X-Rite i1pro is presented here, along with subsequent statistical analysis. The results of this appendix were presented at International Symposium on Archaeometry, Tampa, Florida. This work has been published in The Open Journal of Archaeometry. Appendix C presents supporting data - necessary for the details of the thesis and reference but not specifically relevant to each chapter or section.
Keywords: Australian Aboriginal Ochre,X-Rite i1Pro,spectroscopy
Subject: Chemistry thesis, Physics thesis
Thesis type: Doctor of Philosophy
School: School of Chemical and Physical Sciences
Supervisor: Associate Professor Claire Lenehan